The ethics of Hercules — Robert Chenault Givler
The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org . If you are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this eBook. Title : The ethics of Hercules A study of man's body as the sole determinant of ethical values Author : Robert Chenault Givler Release date : April 29, 2023 [eBook #70666] Language : English Original publication : United States: Alfred A. Knopf, 1924 Other information and formats : www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/70666 Credits : Bob Taylor, Tim Lindell and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images generously made available by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.) THE ETHICS OF HERCULES The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg SOME BORZOI TEXT BOOKS SOCIOLOGY AND POLITICAL THEORY Harry E. Barnes THE ORAL STUDY OF LITERATURE Algernon Tassin THE BASIS OF SOCIAL THEORY Albert G. A. Balz ESSAYS IN ECONOMIC THEORY Simon Nelson Patten THE ETHICS OF JOURNALISM Nelson A. Crawford THE TREND OF ECONOMICS Various Writers AN ANALYSIS OF WRITING Harold P. Scott The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg THE ETHICS OF HERCULES A Study of Man’s Body as the Sole Determinant of Ethical Values BY ROBERT CHENAULT GIVLER, Ph.D. Professor of Philosophy in Tufts College NEW YORK ALFRED · A · KNOPF MCMXXIV The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg COPYRIGHT, 1924, BY ALFRED A. KNOPF, INC. Published, March, 1924 Set up, electrotyped, and printed by the Vail-Ballou Press, Inc., Binghamton, N. Y. Paper furnished by W. F. Etherington & Co., New York. Bound by H. Wolff Estate, New York. PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg DEDICATED TO THE THOUSAND MEN OF MY GENERATION WHOSE THOUGHT I HAVE THE HONOR OF MAKING ARTICULATE. The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg “ Waste not free energy; treasure it and make the best use of it. ” Wilhelm Ostwald , “ The Imperative of Energetics .” The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg PREFACE This book deals with ethics as a strictly natural science, and particularly as a branch of mechanistic psychology. It regards the realm of ethics as coterminous with the arena of human activity, and holds that the problems of conduct, being exclusively man’s problems, are to be solved by the methods of applied science. Moreover, since human conduct is in the last analysis dependent upon the postures and manœuvres of our muscle-fabric, he who would understand ethics must first comprehend something of the mechanics of the human organism. Indeed, this book attempts to show, not only that ethics and physiology can no longer be studied apart from one another, but also that it is the structure and functions of the human body which have determined just what our ethical values are. Such a program is not strictly original, for the student of philosophy will readily find its antecedents. Nevertheless, while many ethical writers have heretofore given numerous intimations of a mechanistic scheme in ethics, yet usually as they proceed to discuss what are called higher things, they seem to forget that it is the human body which performs every human action, even those deeds which move us most profoundly. No such faltering, we trust, will be found in these pages. Indeed, it may be stated at the outset that one of the fundamental conceptions from which this book originated is that the well-being of the physiological organism is the final criterion of whatever is ethically valuable. The title, “The Ethics of Hercules,” is doubly symbolical. Those who have heard of this ancient hero will immediately recognize the emphasis which is placed upon that type of personality who with strength, skill, and persistence works out the problem that lies nearest at hand. Moreover, Hercules the valiant, the thoroughbred who never once shirked from his task, is here contrasted with Cinderella, the patron goddess of all those ineffectual dreamers, who, instead of balancing their ethical books day by day, whimper after the supernatural, and cultivate an inner life of subterfuge and disorder. We hold here that no man can have freedom given to him, but that he must earn it by positively constructive, honest efforts to adjust himself to and gain control of his environment. The motto of Cinderella is, “Where you are not, there is happiness,” while the motto of Hercules is, “Friends lost, something lost; honor lost, much lost; pluck lost, all lost.” The realization that in all science many false starts are made before a single true one is achieved, makes for caution and vigilance. Seeing, however, that the trend of ethical thought has been continually growing more and more mechanistic, it seems not unlikely that we are at the beginning rather than at the end of a chapter in the empirical science of human nature. If this book utters no more than the first sentence of that chapter, the effort will not have been in vain. The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg CONTENTS I. Introduction 3 II. A Physiological Explanation of the Antagonism between All Such Words as “Good” and “Bad,” and “Right” and “Wrong” 12 III. The Biological Signification of the Word “Good” 36 IV. The Action-Patterns Implied by the Word “Bad,” with a Note on the Physiology of “Evil” 58 V. “Right” as a Gestural Sign 75 VI. The Meaning of the Word “Wrong” 116 VII. “Virtue” and “Vice” as Functions of the Organism 127 VIII. Is Conscience Always a Pathological Phenomenon? 155 IX. The Mitigation of the Conflict between Freedom and Obligation 175 X. The Acquisition of an Ethical Technique 189 Index 203 The Ethics of Hercules | Project Gutenberg THE ETHICS OF HERCULES CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION It would be an impertinence for an amateur in physiological science to assert that the significance of ethical values can be understood only through a study